Best swimming pool contractors in Fort Myers
These are the 15 highest-scoring swimming pool contractors in Fort Myers, ranked by our methodology, which weighs rating, review volume, recency, sentiment, and verification together. The list covers the full range of pool work: screening and cages, new construction, resurfacing, maintenance, and repair, since most Fort Myers outfits do more than one of these.
Deck and surface specialists who focus mainly on resurfacing and renovation are covered in more depth on our best pool remodeling & renovation list; a couple of the same names appear here because they also score well on overall service.
Picks are ranked by score and relevance to swimming pool contractor, so a lower overall score can rank higher here.
1. Key Screening
4.9 (344)score 93/100
Key Screening posts the highest score on this list, built on 344 reviews with a near-perfect rating. Reviewers repeatedly point to fast turnaround and fair pricing when they've compared quotes against competitors, and the team's range extends into patio and lanai work beyond straight screening.
Services: pool decking hardscape, deck builder, pool design construction, hot tub repair service
2. Pool Troopers
4.8 (475)score 91/100
Pool Troopers combines a large review base (475) with consistently named technicians who handle both routine chemistry and stubborn repair problems in one visit. It's a solid pick for owners who want one company to cover weekly service and equipment fixes.
Services: pool cleaning maintenance, swimming pool contractor, pool repair equipment, pool design construction
3. Superior Surfacing
4.9 (116)score 90/100
Superior Surfacing earns a 4.9 rating across 116 reviews for its Resilion deck systems, with customers describing the finish as both durable (one survived Hurricane Ian) and comfortable underfoot. Over two decades in business, the team is known for upfront pricing and custom color work, including glitter finishes.
Services: pool decking hardscape, deck builder, hot tub repair service, swimming pool contractor
4. Superior Pools Of Southwest Florida
4.8 (113)score 88/100
Superior Pools of Southwest Florida builds a reputation on on-time construction (often 3-6 months) paired with a designer, Michael, who reviewers say genuinely listens to what they want. Weekly email updates and a hands-on pool school after handoff round out the build experience.
Services: pool remodeling renovation, swimming pool contractor, pool decking hardscape, deck builder
5. Ocean Blue Swimming Pool Services
4.8 (272)score 88/100
Ocean Blue runs a large maintenance operation (272 reviews) built around consistent weekly visits from the same technician, with water clarity as a recurring highlight. Operating in Southwest Florida since 2008 under a Florida contractor license, they publish a starting price for full-service plans.
Watch out: One customer alleged missed services and overbilling, though recent reviews don't show a pattern of this.
Services: pool cleaning maintenance, pool remodeling renovation, pool repair equipment, emergency same day service
6. Custom Pools by Design
4.8 (86)score 87/100
Custom Pools by Design stands out for finishing projects weeks or months ahead of schedule, with named staff overseeing each phase from design through startup. Reviewers, including other subcontractors in the region, single it out for organization and honest sales.
Services: pool cleaning maintenance, pool remodeling renovation, swimming pool contractor, pool decking hardscape
7. Jackson Pools, Inc.
4.9 (159)score 87/100
Jackson Pools runs a structured 90-day build process with named project managers and live progress access, and most reviewers describe strong craftsmanship and follow-up pool school. It's a high-volume builder (159 reviews at 4.9) with a couple of notable aftercare complaints worth weighing.
Watch out: Two reviewers reported startup or finish problems and difficulty reaching their project manager afterward.
Services: pool remodeling renovation, swimming pool contractor, pool decking hardscape, deck builder
8. Gold Coast Pools
5 (44)score 86/100
Gold Coast Pools has built four years of near-universal praise around fast heater installs, often same day to within a week, and a no-upfront-payment policy that reviewers call out repeatedly. Lead technician Steve shows up by name across most reviews for detailed answers and honest work.
Watch out: Review count (44) is smaller than some others on this list, though the pattern of praise is consistent.
Services: swimming pool contractor, deck builder, pool repair equipment, pool design construction
9. Spiro Custom Pools
4.6 (151)score 84/100
Spiro Custom Pools puts owner Jeff directly into design and problem-solving, and most customers describe a smooth build with fair pricing and no upsell pressure. The company also runs an aftercare and maintenance program that keeps clients coming back for repeat work.
Watch out: A couple of reviewers mention a slow start before Jeff's direct management sped things up, and one missed appointment with no callback.
Services: pool cleaning maintenance, pool remodeling renovation, swimming pool contractor, deck builder
10. Colonial Pool & Spa, Inc.
4.8 (301)score 82/100
Colonial Pool & Spa draws on 12 years of reviews for leak detection and liner replacement that other companies couldn't solve, with owner Robert and manager Jack earning consistent praise for responsiveness. It's a high-volume operation (301 reviews) with generally strong technical results.
Watch out: One paver/renovation project saw miscommunication between crew members and unresponsive follow-up on problems.
Services: pool cleaning maintenance, pool remodeling renovation, swimming pool contractor, deck builder
11. Bahama Pools of Southwest Florida Inc
4.8 (34)score 82/100
Bahama Pools answers the phone with a live person, a small but notable detail reviewers mention, and keeps clients updated through both new builds and refinishes. Named staff (Danny, Shelia, Jim) return years later for upgrades and damage repairs, which speaks to their aftercare.
Watch out: Review count (34) is on the lower side, so read as a smaller but consistent sample.
Services: pool cleaning maintenance, pool remodeling renovation, swimming pool contractor, pool decking hardscape
12. Cutting Edge Homes & Renovations
5 (24)score 82/100
Cutting Edge Homes & Renovations is a father-and-son operation with 35+ years combined experience that spans kitchens, roofs, and wind mitigation alongside licensed pool contracting. Local construction and real estate professionals specifically call them out as the area's most reliable builders.
Watch out: Smaller review base (24) though ratings are a perfect 5.0.
Services: pool decking hardscape, pool remodeling renovation, swimming pool contractor, swimming pool
13. A&E Pools, Llc
4.8 (48)score 81/100
A&E Pools handles permitting and HOA submissions in-house, which reviewers highlight when projects need extra paperwork navigated alongside the build itself. The company covers new construction, resurfacing, decking, and landscape integration, with Ely and crew keeping clients informed on materials and budget.
Watch out: A scheduling mishap around initial contact was reported, though the company apologized and addressed it.
Services: pool cleaning maintenance, pool remodeling renovation, swimming pool contractor, deck builder
14. Pool Repairs Plus
4.8 (24)score 80/100
Dave Mann runs Pool Repairs Plus solo with 30+ years of experience, and the reviews consistently describe same-day diagnosis on pump and heater problems along with upfront, honest pricing. Several customers mention he'll fix issues other contractors called unfixable.
Watch out: Smaller review base (24), though feedback is uniformly positive.
Services: pool repair equipment, hot tub repair service, swimming pool contractor, swimming pool
15. Ultimate Pool Care & Repair
5 (20)score 80/100
Ultimate Pool Care & Repair is a smaller, veteran-owned outfit where Brad personally handles emergencies and documents each job with photos and videos. Reviewers describe him going beyond the call, including replacing equipment at his own cost to keep a pool running.
Watch out: Review base is the smallest on this list (20), so treat the perfect rating as an early but consistent signal.
Services: pool cleaning maintenance, pool remodeling renovation, deck builder, pool repair equipment