Edgewater Pools & Spas vs Sweetwater Pool Service: which is better for remodeling?

Updated 2026-07-27 · 5,051 reviewed · 200 listed · How we rank ›

Both of these Naples contractors show up as genuine options for a remodel, but they earn their reputations in different ways. This comparison, built on our methodology, weighs Edgewater Pools & Spas against Sweetwater Pool Service specifically on what matters for a renovation job: design capability, project complexity, and who backs the work once the concrete cures.

Side by side

Criterion	Edgewater Pools & Spas \| Main Office	Sweetwater Pool Service
Google rating	4.9 (399 reviews)	4.7 (157 reviews)
Services	custom luxury features, pool decking hardscape, deck builder, pool cleaning maintenance	custom luxury features, pool decking hardscape, deck builder, pool cleaning maintenance
Best for large-scope renovation	Strong fit, named leads handle complex jobs others turn down	Better suited to resurfacing and targeted repairs than full redesigns
Post-remodel accountability	In-house warranty service keeps them on the hook after completion	Follows up to confirm equipment works, but no stated warranty program
Permitting-heavy projects	Office staff explicitly handle permits and HOA approval	No mention of permit or HOA handling in the data
Verification	Google-verified	Google-verified
Composite score	93	88

Google rating: Edgewater Pools & Spas | Main Office: 4.9 (399 reviews); Sweetwater Pool Service: 4.7 (157 reviews)
Services: Edgewater Pools & Spas | Main Office: custom luxury features, pool decking hardscape, deck builder, pool cleaning maintenance; Sweetwater Pool Service: custom luxury features, pool decking hardscape, deck builder, pool cleaning maintenance
Best for large-scope renovation: Edgewater Pools & Spas | Main Office: Strong fit, named leads handle complex jobs others turn down; Sweetwater Pool Service: Better suited to resurfacing and targeted repairs than full redesigns
Post-remodel accountability: Edgewater Pools & Spas | Main Office: In-house warranty service keeps them on the hook after completion; Sweetwater Pool Service: Follows up to confirm equipment works, but no stated warranty program
Permitting-heavy projects: Edgewater Pools & Spas | Main Office: Office staff explicitly handle permits and HOA approval; Sweetwater Pool Service: No mention of permit or HOA handling in the data
Verification: Edgewater Pools & Spas | Main Office: Google-verified; Sweetwater Pool Service: Google-verified
Composite score: Edgewater Pools & Spas | Main Office: 93; Sweetwater Pool Service: 88

What reviewers say

Edgewater Pools & Spas | Main Office

Edgewater Pools earns consistent praise for smooth pool design and construction backed by named leads like Colton and Moose, who deliver on timelines and manage complex renovations where other contractors shy away. Their weekly maintenance crews (Samuel, Lester, Jose, Juan, and Ron among them) build long-term trust by showing up reliably, catching problems early, and treating both pools and homeowners with genuine care.

Staff move efficiently across repair work, equipment installation, and cosmetic renovation. The company differs from typical pool builders by maintaining their own warranty service rather than abandoning customers post-sale. Office staff like Katrina and Kat handle permitting and HOA coordination without glitches.

Sweetwater Pool Service

Most customers stay loyal for years, praising Sweetwater's technicians for thorough problem-solving, honest equipment advice, and transparency during renovations. Staff like Chris, Jacob, Jorge, and Ken consistently earn recognition for showing up on time, explaining work clearly, and catching issues other companies missed, all at prices reviewers found lower than alternatives.

The company handles everything from weekly maintenance to major resurfacing and leak repairs without cutting corners. Even after jobs finish, they follow up to ensure equipment works correctly and customers understand how to care for their pools. Customers explicitly recommend them to new pool owners and trust them enough to delegate multiple service types.

Which should you pick?

Pick Edgewater Pools & Spas | Main Office if

Your project involves a full redesign, structural changes, or a scope other contractors have balked at
You want an in-house warranty on the finished renovation instead of a one-time handoff
You need permitting or HOA approval managed as part of the job

Pick Sweetwater Pool Service if

Your remodel is more about resurfacing, equipment upgrades, or leak repair than structural redesign
You want a contractor known for pricing below competitors and explaining every step
You value long-term staff continuity and follow-up education on new equipment

Verdict

The choice comes down to how big and structurally complex the remodel is. For a full-scale renovation, especially one with permitting, HOA sign-off, or design challenges other contractors have turned down, Edgewater's named leadership and in-house warranty make it the safer bet for staying accountable after the work is done. If the job leans more toward resurfacing, leak repair, or equipment upgrades, Sweetwater's reputation for fair pricing and clear communication makes it a strong, less expensive alternative. Edgewater's higher composite score and larger review base reflect a broader track record, but Sweetwater's sentiment score is essentially on par, so the decision should follow the scope of the job rather than the numbers alone.

[ {"q": "Which contractor is better for a full pool renovation with structural changes?", "a": "Edgewater Pools & Spas, since its named leads are specifically praised for managing complex renovations and its in-house warranty covers the work after completion."}, {"q": "Which is the more affordable option for remodeling?", "a": "Sweetwater Pool Service is repeatedly noted for pricing lower than competitors, making it a reasonable choice for smaller-scope remodel work like resurfacing."}, {"q": "Does either company handle permits and HOA approval for a remodel?", "a": "Edgewater's office staff are specifically credited with handling permitting and HOA coordination; this isn't mentioned in Sweetwater's data."}, {"q": "Who has the stronger overall track record?", "a": "Edgewater has a higher composite score (92.5 vs 88.3) and more reviews (399 vs 157), though both businesses show strong positive sentiment."} ]

Need help choosing?

Tell us about your project once and compare quotes from swimming pool contractor in Naples.

Enquiries submitted through our forms may be shared with partner providers who can perform the work, and we may receive a referral fee. Our rankings and scores are based only on our published method and are not influenced by referral fees.