Superior Pools of Southwest Florida vs Slusser Pools: which fits your outdoor pool build?

Updated 2026-07-27 · 5,051 reviewed · 200 listed · How we rank ›

Both outfits build outdoor pools in the Naples area and both show up with strong review volume, so this comes down to how each one handles the build itself. The comparison below follows our methodology and focuses on communication reliability and finish quality, the two things that most often make or break an outdoor pool project.

Side by side

Criterion	Superior Pools Of Southwest Florida	Slusser Pools - License CPC1456712
Google rating	4.8 (113 reviews)	4.7 (159 reviews)
Services	pool remodeling renovation, swimming pool contractor, pool decking hardscape, deck builder	custom luxury features, pool decking hardscape, deck builder, pool cleaning maintenance
Verification	Google-verified	Google-verified
Composite score	88	83

Google rating: Superior Pools Of Southwest Florida: 4.8 (113 reviews); Slusser Pools - License CPC1456712: 4.7 (159 reviews)
Services: Superior Pools Of Southwest Florida: pool remodeling renovation, swimming pool contractor, pool decking hardscape, deck builder; Slusser Pools - License CPC1456712: custom luxury features, pool decking hardscape, deck builder, pool cleaning maintenance
Verification: Superior Pools Of Southwest Florida: Google-verified; Slusser Pools - License CPC1456712: Google-verified
Composite score: Superior Pools Of Southwest Florida: 88; Slusser Pools - License CPC1456712: 83

What reviewers say

Superior Pools Of Southwest Florida

Owners consistently report smooth builds completed on schedule by a crew that treats properties with care and stays in touch throughout. Michael handles design with attention to needs; Ben and construction teams execute flawlessly; Wes provides hands-on pool school and ongoing support. Weekly emails, same-day responses, and meticulous attention keep customers confident.

Slusser Pools - License CPC1456712

Most customers report excellent builds and renovations completed on or ahead of schedule, with Kenny and his team personally invested in outcomes. Staff including Chad, Dustin, and Michelle earn consistent praise for professionalism. One detailed complaint describes permitting delays, mid-project communication breakdowns, staffing transitions, and a rough pebble finish that caused skin injuries-issues the company resolved only after BBB intervention.

Strengths include warranty support, emergency response (one owner praised unsolicited Hurricane Milton assistance), and willingness to upgrade work within budget. The business claims operation since 1980 and holds license CPC1456712. Builders should verify project scope in writing and confirm post-job communication protocols upfront.

Verdict

For an outdoor pool build where finish quality and steady communication matter most, Superior Pools of Southwest Florida is the safer pick. Its review record shows a cleaner track record on both fronts, with Michael's design involvement and Wes's pool school rounding out the experience. Slusser Pools still earns strong marks overall and its owner-onsite approach and warranty support are real advantages, but the documented dispute over a rough pebble finish and mid-project communication gaps is worth weighing carefully if you're pouring a new pool rather than doing renovation work with a well-defined scope.

Need help choosing?

Tell us about your project once and compare quotes from swimming pool contractor in Naples.

Enquiries submitted through our forms may be shared with partner providers who can perform the work, and we may receive a referral fee. Our rankings and scores are based only on our published method and are not influenced by referral fees.