Platinum Pavers of SWFL vs Key Screening: which is better for pool decking and hardscape?
The differences that matter
- Core specialty vs added service. Platinum Pavers of SWFL is built around paver installation, coping, and patio redesign, while Key Screening's paver and hardscape work sits alongside its main business of pool cages and rescreening.
- Fixing prior contractor mistakes. Platinum Pavers of SWFL has a specific reputation for repairing coping and paver jobs that other contractors botched, which Key Screening's summary doesn't mention.
- Scale of hardscape crew. Platinum Pavers of SWFL fields a crew of 4+ installers dedicated to paver and deck work, often finishing in a single day, whereas Key Screening's crew capacity is described more generally across its full service range.
- Track record length. Key Screening brings 25+ years in business and licensing/bonding credentials to point to, while Platinum Pavers of SWFL's edge comes from its higher rating and owner-led oversight rather than years in operation.
- Rating and review volume. Platinum Pavers of SWFL holds a perfect 5.0 from 442 reviews against Key Screening's 4.9 from 344, a small but real gap given both have high review counts.
Side by side
- Google rating
- Platinum Pavers of SWFL: 5 (442 reviews)
- Key Screening: 4.9 (344 reviews)
- Services
- Platinum Pavers of SWFL: deck builder, pool decking hardscape, swimming pool contractor, swimming pool
- Key Screening: pool decking hardscape, deck builder, pool design construction, hot tub repair service
- Best for
- Platinum Pavers of SWFL: Paver patios, coping repair, and deck resurfacing as the primary job
- Key Screening: Pool cage or lanai projects where paver/patio work is bundled in
- Owner involvement
- Platinum Pavers of SWFL: Eddie personally oversees every project, per reviews
- Key Screening: Alec's team runs jobs with named staff (Erica Jones, Joe H.) handling communication
- Verification
- Platinum Pavers of SWFL: Google-verified
- Key Screening: Google-verified
- Composite score
- Platinum Pavers of SWFL: 95
- Key Screening: 93
Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.
What reviewers say
Platinum Pavers of SWFL
Eddie and his crew show up on time and fix what other contractors left broken. Reviewers consistently praise the owner's hands-on approach, the team's skill, and fast turnaround on everything from pool coping to entire patio redesigns. Projects get done clean, priced fairly, and Eddie follows up afterward to confirm satisfaction.
Homeowners mention pool tile installation, paver leveling, coping repair, deck work, pressure washing, and sealing. The crew arrived in force (four skilled workers noted in one review) and often completed jobs in a single day. One customer was so pleased they added 270 sq ft to expand the original patio based on crew suggestions.
Key Screening
Reviewers consistently report smooth, responsive service from initial quote through completion. Alec's team handles pool cages, rescreening, patio expansions, and lanai enclosures with strong communication and punctual execution. Staff adapt to customer scheduling needs and leave properties clean; multiple reviewers named Erica Jones and Joe H. for prompt, helpful support.
Quality and fair pricing emerge as key draws. Several reviewed comparing Key Screening against other firms and chose them for professionalism and value. Turnover is quick (often same-day or within days), and the crew respects properties during work. Referrals from satisfied neighbors and repeat customers appear routine.
Which should you pick?
Pick Platinum Pavers of SWFL if
- Your project is primarily paver, coping, or patio deck work rather than screening
- You've had a bad experience with a previous paver contractor and need repairs done right
- You want an owner personally checking the job site and following up after completion
Pick Key Screening if
- You need a pool cage, rescreening, or lanai enclosure alongside your patio work
- You value a long-established, licensed and bonded company with 25+ years in the area
- You want a company that's already proven itself against competitors on price and professionalism
Verdict
For a job that's mainly pool decking and hardscape, Platinum Pavers of SWFL is the more direct fit: it's a paver and patio specialist with a crew built for that work and a track record of cleaning up other contractors' mistakes. Key Screening makes sense if your project pairs decking with a pool cage or rescreening job, since it can handle both under one roof with a long-standing, licensed operation behind it. Both post strong ratings, so the choice comes down to whether decking is the whole job or one piece of a larger enclosure project.
Need help choosing?
Tell us about your project once and compare quotes from swimming pool contractor in Naples.
Enquiries submitted through our forms may be shared with partner providers who can perform the work, and we may receive a referral fee. Our rankings and scores are based only on our published method and are not influenced by referral fees.
FAQ
- Which company is better for paver patio installation alone?
- Platinum Pavers of SWFL, since paver and coping work is its core specialty and reviewers specifically praise its crew's speed and craftsmanship on those jobs.
- Which company should I call if I also need a pool cage or rescreening?
- Key Screening, since it handles cages and lanai enclosures as its main business and can bundle in patio or paver work.
- Does either company have a reputation for fixing other contractors' work?
- Yes, Platinum Pavers of SWFL is specifically noted for repairing coping and paver jobs left broken by previous contractors.
- How do their ratings compare?
- Platinum Pavers of SWFL has a 5.0 rating from 442 reviews, and Key Screening has 4.9 from 344 reviews.